Touhou Recueillement

Yeah, Cherub first wall :3 Congratulation ^_^ "Recueillement" means meditation. The cleaning looks nice but I think that cropping the top makes it lose some depth somehow. Looking forward for more wallpaper coming from you ;3 +fav

Absolutely awesome wallpaper!!! Fav for me!

So basically this is just nothing more than a scan clean-up (rather uninteresting I have to say). To be honest, after watching the original scan, I gotta say that the clean-up this scan needed wasn’t really that much or that complicated to begin with. I can’t help but to wonder if there is more to this wallpaper than just that.

Anyhow, I think you should have done more to this than just clean it up. In the end, there is absolutely nothing here to be really critique. The art is neat though (kudos to the original artist that painted the whole thing).

Fantastic wallpaper you made here !! +Fav

If I could do more than /fave it I would.

Amazing @_@!

first wall! congrats!!!! you did an awesome job cleaning the scan^^ it looks good^^

A wallie from cheru??? rub my eyes XD

Back to the wallie. The cleaning is good. However, just like Mou mentioned, perhaps you cropped the upper part of the scan too much and kinda lose the depth. Besides, in my opinion, maybe textures and some effects can be added to further enhance the wallie.

Anyway, I like it the way it is. Looking forward to see another wallie from my dear cherub. Fav it!

Wow, this wall cleanup is absolutely beautiful!~~ I like Touhou wallpapers, and I like the details on the pillars. :3 Fav+

ooo i need to try this on my desktop. +Fav'd

First of all congratulations on your first wallpaper. I was interested in your wallpaper at first but it's a let down seeing that it's a scan cleanup. I would have to agree on zero-r - the things needed to be cleaned aren't complicated - just a straight vertical line and cropping off the top part. You might have played with the colors but you made it lack its contrast like everything's washed out.

This

is a very good example of a wallpaper that is scan clean up but at the same time not just a scan clean up. Although it has this vertical line like yours it was also cleaned off and at the same time the chandelier is cleaned out of the picture as well. Lighting is also enhanced in this picture which is very evident when you compare the scan from the wallpaper and this is what a wallpaper should be if it's going to be one using a clean up.

Hope you'll do more wallpapers, not just a scan clean up. Keep it up.

It may just be a clean-up but I think it's done very well. Though, I also have to agree with moutonzare about the loss of depth from cropping. Maybe a 1920x1200 resolution can fix that up. Anyways, it looks great! /fav

Beautiful work with the cleanup, however i have to agree with the others that the cropping took from the depth of the wall. Other than that it is a great wall, love the atmosphere and the mood... +fav looking forward to see other walls from you ;)

Good job on cleaning the scan up. Fabulous choice of source material! Love it.

This may just be a scan clean-up, but I do like how you enhanced the colors and lighting. It looks quite nice.

congrats!!!! I love all the details.... and the mage look awesome

Like the dark style

Awesome wallpaper!!

I don't know that Clean Up Scans will not be rejected, nice.. +Fav

"No Matter How Gifted You Are, You Alone Can't Change The World.."

L. Lawliet

become to my wallpaper.Love the theme and the deep color and it seems so mysterious.

This looks really stunning!! Good job!!

A gorgeous picture I'm quite fond of it

HOT DAMN! Look at all those of Scarlet Devil Mansion's crew... and how their appearances are buffed up by cherub's doing.

Remilia looks tons more sexier than before. Flandre seems in control and deadlier due to that fact. Sakuya removed the stereotypical maid outfit for that elegant looking gown. Patchi---what---from plain moe to badass moe?? Then to Koakuma. Same old, same old, still nice though.

Anyways a whole heck of a +1 for you and keep it up! More power :3 master... o/

Nice xD

Whoa!

The Scan has alot of depth that seems to be missing here. But that shouldn't stop you for making an effort and taking on the challenge and doin what you want. That's what you did and that's what i liked about you. It's your first wall and i think for that you did treat it fairly well. For the critique i'd just say work on the depth, details and shadows.. that alone should carve a better revision outta it. Then you can do stuff with Bg and characters if you'd want to.

I hope this helps and i didn't sound too harsh. For the revisions and upcoming works.. Gambatte ne~ n_n

a superb wallpaper....this is amazing

That is an awesome paper that you make, i like it very much. Love it...

I'm new to this, where's the button to like this more than once?