what a perfect wall to add during this time of year, haha thats pretty creative i like that. The wall itself is really neat, the art of it is kinda different though, not in a bad way, just different. The lighting is also nice i like that. and besides Gakuen Alice =) one of the cutest walls i seen yet for this series. keep up the fine creative ideas.

Great concept, however there are several flaws in your execution.

The character extractions could be cleaner, and the blending, lighting and colors could use some work. As a critique I would recommend softening the shadows, and cleaning up the characters a bit more. I would also (since you are going for the cartoony look) Use some flat color rather than shading. It would really help push it an a better direction. It is a great start though.

I hope my crit helps you as you progress.

This is good! I like it.

Very cute Halloween wallpaper. I like the play perspective with the subjects being flat paper cut outs.

cute wall their costumes are good....i love it now i know...what wall i will use WHEN IT"S HALLOWEEN (great job in short)

cute wall their costumes are good....i love it now i know...what wall i will use WHEN IT"S HALLOWEEN (great job in short)

ahh...perfect time for a halloween wallpaper background. =) Thanks for it!.. +download!

Cute wall ^^ Love the background and really suit the title. *fav*

Ahh...that brings back memories... -(n#n)-

Haha, cute wall. I like it.

+fav

Oh gosh! Another Gakuen Alice Wallie! I'm sure glad you picked this Halloween scan. Mikan-chan is so kawaii in her witch costume. It has a great concept.

The extractions need improvement. You could do some shadow effects. And the background is not really that realistic. The scan doesn't seem to blend well. But it's cute and I like it.

Mikan Cawaii >x< thank you

Oooh, cute and dark, just my favourite kind of wallpaper! The background and the characters don't seem to fit well together, and the tree looks kinda odd, but still. Good job :)

yay! gakuen alice wallie XD !! dark background, doesnt fit with the anime .. but it's nice^^

Perfect for the halloween, it's really nice.

I love there attire

The colors are really good

you've better give them candy or else...

the background brings out the cuteness really well XDDD my only critique would be that the characters seems a little big for the background? It's still a lovely Halloween wallie, though ^^

I got this wallpaper too late for halloween, but I'll definitely save it for next year. Good job!

What a kawai Halloween wallpaper!

Not bad! You did quite a good job on this wallpaper ^^

Great background!, especially the shadows, good work!

the whole effect is just so adorable very nice background made

cute wall you made, all the characters in alice academy looks so CUTE i like it keep making more walls

wow... this is really good! i love the picture u used from a wallpaper an i love their halloween outfits - so kawaii!! |(VcV)| but mikan an hotaru r floating.. /(O_O)/

I really like the idea you've got here. ^_^ It's very cute!

The scan itself needs to be cleaned up a little bit however and the background, as you said, looks a little too 3d for the image (usually artist don't get 3D enough!). I think that if you cleaned the scan and blurred the shadows on the concrete this would bring the 2 together a lot better.

The starry sky looks really good however, I wouldn't change that at all.

Yay!!! The Gakuen Alice gang strolling around on Halloween night! I've seen a few wallpapers with the same scan and I'll have to say I like this the best :)

(n_n)/

nice wallpaper... the dead tree and the red moon gives it a nice creepy fell..

good job on your wall!

(n_n)~

Natsume looks so cute with the cat ears. I love it.

i like this too.

you are a great designer i love the wall it looks so reality i love the grace

i love the shadow but there is one thing i couldn't understand

its the moon why is it red but i think it gives the wall a spacial look

anyway great work

with all my love

xbritneyx

It is very cute and beautiful. I like this one.

This is a very cute theme. I love the expressions on their faces. Well Done! Lady

Awwww dis is just too adorable! <3 love d costumes 8)E

Trick or treat!

I like this paper!

this is really cute!!! though they seem a little "floating" but it's really nice =)) rabbit with pumpkin head, that's sooo cute! :)

nice

oohh~~a halloween theme wallpaper!!!

i really can use this but only during halloween 8)E

thank you for making this <3

you did a great job of this XD

Usual problems with the render itself, they are just not enough clean, though guess vectoring them would be kind a pain. The shadows could use some more gauusian blur, in a dark background like this is hard to expect such sharp shadows as is now. Except those flaws I actually kinda like this pece, it has a interesting atmposphere, which is kinda hard to explain for me.