pookakitten

Nice vector. I think you did a good job extending her sock/toe.

I like this wallpaper. The only quibble I have with it is I think Asuna's hair is too dark.

I like how you included an "in progress" image. Your method is interesting-I do the base color first and then any shading, while you do the opposite. I also like how you gave us both variants of her outfit because I prefer the original.

The one thing that seems off about this vector is the white on her skin is too extreme, especially with the haloing on her leg and breasts. Honestly it looks like she's got a rash.

I'm sure someone else will suggest extending her hair so the vector can be used with more options. If it's within your skill set, consider revising this one or doing so in the future.

The monochrome color scheme is made more striking by the use of color for her eyes.

I prefer version 2 and how you adjusted Madara's coloring to match the different color scheme. This wallpaper that got me to try out the manga.

I really like the flowers and butterflies on the kimono billowing out behind him.

Seamless extension of the scan.

I like the colors, and the wings remind me of the author's other series, Sword Art Online in its second arc. I'm undecided on the extra butterflies. I think they might be too "glowy" and distract from the girl.

It's quite nice, though her eyes don't work for me. The painted effect is very effective on her armor.

Really well done for most of the background and the girl. I especially love the details on the lace. They're phenomenal

The one problem I have with this is the lamp. When I saw this on the front page, I thought it was cut and pasted into the image. Looking at the source image it's still there, but I think the vectoring made this shortcoming of the original more noticeable. I admit, I don't have any suggestions how to lessen this and removing the lamp would be very difficult to do with the patterns on the floor.

I like how you made it look like a news broadcast. Even better, it's one of my favorite series, one I think is underrated.

I think the vector's outlining is very well done--it makes me think of a pencil sketch. You could improve it by using more shading. Show how her dress drapes, for example. Right now it looks very flat.

Would it be possible for you to upload a textless version?

I really like this wallpaper. The extraction of Yeul is well done to my uneducated eye. I really like that you included a version without the text.

What creeps me out every time I see this is it looks like she has no iris or pupil in her eyes.

I really like version 1. The color balance is better than version 3 to my eyes. I also love version 2 with its black and white highlights the woman with her dress.

I can't see where you knitted the two pages together which is well done.

I like version 4 the most because of the contrast between the colors. In all the versions, I think something is off about her mouth. Is that light spot on her lips a reflection or supposed to be her teeth?

Much improved from your previous works. The shading looks better. What is that silver thing on the top of Yuki's hand?

What scan did you use as your source?

I like this one and downloaded version 3. I like how the color scheme varies in the different versions, though my least favorite is the desaturated version because there is not much to draw the eye.

When I first saw this wallpaper, I thought it was a new Vampire Knight picture because it had the feel of Matsuri Hino's work.

Nice, but maybe next time use a more realistic cloud brush or stock.

I like version 1 better. More contrast or something in the background. The simple background lets the vector shine, but it doesn't look like you just slapped the vector onto a blank background.

Great job creating the crow from scratch.

My favorite was version 1-I just didn't like the eraser. Personal preference. I'm glad you gave us different choices. A great job overall.

I like version 2 better. The colors add something to the overall image. In contrast, version 1 is just so neutral.