Ok, first one,
I need some help to fix the backround i dont know what to do with it



And second one


pls tell me what you think about it
i like the naruto in the center with the fire whirl around but i m not so happy with the faces and the letters...

anyway tell me what you think

The first wallpaper, did you add some effect to the character in the background, because the edges look really chopped up. I do not know if you did that on purpose or not but it does not look that great. Also not into that negative effect look, but that is probally personal taste.

The second wallpaper, the swirl looks nice. That said, i think the extraction of the two characters (which are cleary from a manga or other black & white source) are not that well executed. It doesnt blend into the background, it just got pasted on to the swirly background and got some % fade to it. The text font doesnt look nice either, try find a better one and dont use a banner like that it just looks really out of place.

Good luck working on it :) and hopefully you will improve it!

Honestly, there's about thinothing exciting s wall. try to figure out a certain theme. if you want to focus on sasuke and naruto then do so dont leave naruto alone at the center.

Hhhmm...for me those two wall...they have a problem with the background..Ap will not accept that kind of simplicity background so If I were you..better work on that..then for that second wall scan..need to improved the extraction job...well..good luck on that!

ONLY ONE WALL FOR THREAD PLEASE!

the first one... has a nice vector.. but the pictures on the right side have ugly effects, and don't look nice... besides the background is to plain.. a bit empty.. you should add more things... like some brushes and some text...

the second wallpaper.. seams really messy...
The character on the right side is bad extracted, i can see some lines that shoulden'tbe there... the scan on the center must be cleaned... cause it's a little bit grainy... and the text is not matching at all with the rest of the wallpaper... besides it's too big, and the square filled with redish color shape has to go... get rid of it

and you forgot to sign the two walls

Well I'm working on them.
But I'm new I have never worked with Photoshop before, so I hope they'll get better.

Rukawa11

hhhmm...for me those two wall...they have a problem with the background..Ap will not accept that kind of simplicity background so If I were you..better work on that..

Well thats why I'm posting it here, I hope to get some ideas.

I don't really have ideas but Love it! you certainly did it well!

Which one do you mean?
Or do you mean both?
Anyway Thanks ^-^