I have made this wall this afternoon, and it was rejected. Is it so ugly ? Maybe it was rejected because I have forgotten to put my signature ?
Where is the problem ?

(Sorry for my approximate English, I'm French)

1. The quality of the pictures of Lacus and Kira are bad.
2. The picture quality of the pictures in the panel on the left are also bad.
3. The text is hardly noticeable
4. Your background is just too busy.

You should probably vector the pictures, and maybe think of a different background. I would also make the text stand out a bit, and not tucked away in between 2 panels.

Well the quality of your scans is bad~~~try to redo it~~~~
I like the way that you put those little pictures on the left~~~~but it's just~~~too rough~~~
and you need to work on your background~~~cuz it looks kinda glare~~~
I believe you can fix all these problems~~~~wait to see a better job~~~

Do not feel down just becuase your wall was rejected, it may not be becuase of the reasons you believe, and many people got their walls turned down but that doesnt stop them from getting better. :) Well, the scan is not clean, true, either it was becuase yiou wanted it that way, or its simply just not clean. After the scan is cleaned, just add a light glow to make the two stand out from the background becuase now they just look blended into stars. Trus in what you do, you'll only get better. :)