Being a total novice here, I know I'm not qualified to comment, but I liked it...

I liked it better than many B and A rated ones I've seen... but then my tastes may not be as 'refined' as some people's. My first anime infatuation was with Inuyasha...

I liked the rich color, but I also appreciate it for it's 'gallery' value not just as a daily background.

Maybe because it also looks like something fresh -- not a rehash.

But I having said that, I've little idea what makes for a good wall and find the critique process more than a bit scary. I may try uploading some scans, given what I've seen there I know I can do at least that well, but given my total newb state in creating any WP's, I'd be very hesitant to try something here even though for me, many of my scans are good enough for WP's for my tastes... (which run toward the simple)...

I'd give it an A- maybe? but My grading skills are poor. I usually prefer floating point values... :-) That way it always leave room for better than I've seen before...