I have mixed feelings over this. I like the concept of the newspaper article. I think it is done very well as well, with the texture of the paper , the font, the print, the layout, the picture and of course the text which is well thought out.

However the pocket watch looks fake-washed out. It doesn't look metallic or as detailed as seen on screen in the series. The wood of the desk also looks more like a laminate than actual grain. This was likely due to the high contrast of the newspaper. With a contrast in that paper, I would have expected the grains of the wood to be of high contrast as well. So the grains in the wood should have been deeper and defined.

The paper being flat also contribute some part to the effect of floating as others mentioned. Curl the edges or add some wrinkles (more difficult).

This looks nice when zoomed out but 1:1 or closeup, the flaws seem evident. The newspaper can stand on its own though.