Established 1 year, 6 months ago

VectaDesu

Voting for VectaDesu Contest #15 - Anime Kermesse 2011

New to AnimePaper? Join our community today!

Avatar for akiranyo
akiranyo Satellizer L. Bridget

4 months, 1 week ago

 

Voting rules

Everybody can vote, who is member on AP at least for a month. Participants cannot vote for own works. By a tie, wins the earlier submitted. How to vote

The ranking system got many complaints due being complicated and too much to write. So we will use now a temporary easy-to-understand system.

You can give 2 points to the entry which you like at most and give additional 1 & 1 points to another two entries which also caught your attention. Just tell the number of the entries or the submitters username.

Commenting on those entries is very welcomed, also giving advices for the entries which you think could be better. (those can be posted on the vectors itself, if you haven't done yet)

Prizes: hopefully the VD staff will get back in this year and we can beat up a bit to make some badges again :3

Entries

-01- @Vampluva

Mechanised Laura

-02- @oge

Yachiyo

-03- @200M

Naomasa

-04- @ClockWorkLemons

Aria

-05- @kori

vector -Sen Yarizui-

-06- @isshi

The Ice Witch

-07- @acidtreat101

Dalian in the Dark

-08- @akiranyo

[vector]Akemi Homura with M249 SAW

-09- SamB

Cyber Power

-10- wonderngo

Cherry Blossom

-11- dolce-yasmin

beautiful dangerous

-12- Yamaro

Exorcisto

-13- TheMajor

Oh Frosty

This thread is closed. You can no longer post in this thread.
Avatar for TheMajor
°TheMajor

4 months, 1 week ago

 

1st: @isshi: The shading and color gradients on this are amazing. The detail and clarity in the eyes make this vector just glow. I can't describe how this makes me feel.

2nd: @wondergo: Such a awesome vector it's just so cute! that kimono is just awesome but actually the hair and hair accessories are the best part of this. So many different angles. Really great job.

&

@akiranyo: My friend what can I say but OMG! That machine gun is just wow! I mean just look at it are you sure it's not real, cause it looks real to me. Such cuteness with such a serious tone. I have commended your skill before but this is different from all the others it alone stands apart. Bravo!

Good luck to everyone... I wish I could have voted for you all but such is life. All the best!

Avatar for acidtreat101
acidtreat101 Watch the Phở out!178794

4 months, 1 week ago

 

Voting is very hard as always and there are some very good works!

1st: Vampluva- This vector is so crisp and clean, no errors, perfect linework, great coloring and shading. It's got STYLE!

2nd: Isshi- Amazing work on the coloring...it looks so...three dimensional and real...I feel like I could reach in and grab her!

3rd: Wonderngo- Such good work on the lineart, I can tell all the work that went into it but even the lines on the smallest piece of design work on her kimono are super clean

Again, great work everyone, there are many other really really good vectors but I could only pick three!

I don't expect my entry to get any points as the others are so good, but please take a look because even though it looks different compared to the other entries, because I did put a lot of work into it!

Avatar for TheMajor
°TheMajor

4 months, 1 week ago

 

Well I like it.... I think sometimes people go with what they know. I actually wish you could have submitted your little alien girl you are working on.

I can see just by looking at the vector you did enter that it's not lac of quality.. but in my personal opinion it's very dark and out of place. It has quality that is way up there, & I believe it deserves a better rating than B-!

Have a fresh cookie they are soft warm & yummy. Don't feel bad, half the time I never make even the top 7. I'm not expecting much either but it sure is fun. hugs

Promise me to never again write yourself off... You are wonderful!

Avatar for RideOnMusic
°RideOnMusic

4 months, 1 week ago

 

1: @Yamaro

2: @dolce-yasmin

3: @wonderngo

Avatar for SamB
°SamB

4 months, 1 week ago

 
  1. Yamaro
  2. Wonderngo
  3. 200M
Avatar for scorpedo
°scorpedo щ(°д°щ)

4 months, 1 week ago

 
  1. (2 pts): @Yamaro
  2. (1 pt): @isshi
  3. (1 pt): @dolce-yasmin
Avatar for Nessbad94
`Nessbad94

4 months, 1 week ago

 

oh, guys there are lots of awesome entires...

Well...

1st @Yamaro - this vector is just something!! It shines&glows&shines has some movement, dynamic feeling..

2nd@Vampluva - just perfect vector with very eye-cathing Vamp's style - with crispy lines&vibrant coloring!

Oh my gawd... I'd still faved all of you.. but..

anyway.. 3rd - @Akiranyo.. I'm just blown out with that realistic gun you made!!!

Again guys, each of you did AMAZING job at your entries and good luck =)

Avatar for Tens
`Tens

4 months, 1 week ago

 

TOO COMPLICATED.

OLD SYSTEM BACK KTHX. JUST KIDDIN' YO.

1ST: @isshi: Tough choice placing the top 3.

I like isshi's vector because I like how the colors mingle with each other. It's like I am digging through a cup of ice cream. The top stimulates my palette with light popping colors. As I make my way down it starts to get deeper and richer. Overall the character's shading feel solid and more believable. Everything blends in with the soft gradients and hard shadows are there to provide contrast and solidify the light source. The boots are really well done and feel like I can go and knock on them to hear a thumping sound.

A solid vector all around and it also comes from Ben-to!

2ND: @TheMajor: DUDE YO. When I first saw this vector on AP I was like WTF MAN y u copy pasta scan and submit it as a vector?! I don't even need to look a the original because I've read a lot of manhwa/manga that had this illustrator. I can say that it's identical.

Features that make this vector stand out is the awesome blending of the shadows and skin. On top of that there's a lot of contrast which appeals to me as a gradient/contrast whore. There's even reflective lighting which makes the character feel more round and believable. Technical-wise this vector went another step ahead of the other entries. That being the reflective lighting and more complicated skin and clothing.

Unfortunately what turned me off is that I was teased and left alone in a deserted plain. The skin and clothing are fantastic to look at. Once you reach the hair and sword I am left with disappointment. They are really flat and lack gradients. I understand that this entry was also last minute. But this creates an undesirable contrast between flat and realism.

Honestly, TheMajor has improved a lot with the submission of this vector. Previously "painted" vectors by TheMajor looked sloppy and random. This vector is a night and day comparison to the others.

3RD: @Yamaro: Yamaro still did a good job despite his vector being done quickly in a week or so. So it's understandable that his vector does not fully express his desired results for it. Despite it being rushed it is still a good vector.

He brought a grainy mute vector to the forefront. The color saturation was jacked up and the blur made his character feel glowy. The most notable feature of his vector is the magenta being added to the eyes. This helps expand the color palette and highlight features of the character. It refreshes the eyes from looking at all the blue.

I feel that Yamaro already knows but the downfall of his vector is the lack of depth shading. The face looks fine but the rest of the body feels flat in comparison to isshi's.

GOOD JOB EVERYONE. FUN-FUN-FUN.

Avatar for Nysha
`Nysha

4 months, 6 days ago

 

Wut. We now have to vote for 3? Arg that makes it hard to decide!! Lots of great entries - I feel bad not giving points to some "honorable mentions". :(

Anyways...

1: @isshi for pretty much what Tens said, though I would describe it more like a cup of rainbow sherbet instead. *___* So much volume and life given to that flat scan!

2: @Yamaro for the excellent quality and satisfying accents of color splashed here and there to spice it up! Your style is softer and more matte - which I think is just fine because it makes your work unique.

3: @akiranyo. Instead of relying on the flashiness of a scan to grab your attention, I like this one for its technical execution. I can appreciate the very subtle gradient transitions and high attention to detail! :D

Still great job to the others too!

Avatar for ArRana
~ArRana

4 months, 4 days ago

 
  1. @wonderngo
  2. @acidtreat101
  3. @TheMajor

edited by akiranyoOnly 3 entries can be voted, I have cut down the rest

Avatar for Horseradish
`Horseradish Live To Rise

4 months, 4 days ago

 

I - @isshi: I really think that it's going to be hard to top your vectors since you always go the extra mile in bringing them to life! I really am amazed (always) whenever you submit something new. And your entry's no exception----making it more vibrant than ever and the extensions are truly genius. (OwO)

II - @dolce-yasmin: Other than what I've said already in your entry, what I like most about your vector is that it has that 3D quality look to it. LOL. IDK but when I view it, it's as if I can touch it----literally. I mean, if you took out the lineart, it will look even more realistic. (OwO)

III - @Yamaro: Choosing the one for the 3rd place is rea-aaaaaaaaally tough. But I gotta give this to my man, Yamaro. \m/ I really have nothing to say about your entry man. It's clean, crisp, spot on----the colors are amazing! I can't wait to see what wall you'll come up with it. :D

Good luck to all those who participated this round! \o\ |o| /o/

Avatar for saiyagok
°saiyagok

4 months, 1 day ago

 

>_> I dislike this voting tedious system, it disregards the other entries so badly :/ it sucks.

    • Yamaro
    • wonderngo
    • TheMajor

I'll be comenting in the vectors. Congrats to everyone i'm glad to see many entries :D

Avatar for kori
~kori

4 months, 7 hours ago

 
  1. dolce-yasmin
  2. isshi
  3. acidtreat101
Avatar for Vampluva
^Vampluva Good cop

3 months, 4 weeks ago

 

My vote -

  1. Isshi

  2. TheMajor

  3. Yamaro

Avatar for Bantam
Bantam bantibeard

3 months, 4 weeks ago

 

Very hard I think all of them deserve it.

  • 1 beautiful dangerous
  • 2 The Ice Witch
  • 3 [vector]Akemi Homura with M249 SAW(awesome gun work!)

Honestly I could have picked them at random they were all so good this round.

Avatar for akiranyo
akiranyo Satellizer L. Bridget

3 months, 4 weeks ago

 

Okay, my voting should be the closing one, if I don't will be lazy and sleep one on it still. Anyways:

@isshi - first, cause it's Ben-To, second cause is a great gradient abusing quality vector.

@TheMajor - first I though it's a scan, but it was a vector. By imptressing me with that (and with bewbs of Satella) a naturally vote by me.

@200M - somebody who improved the most in latest time, need give my regards there, plus is a Horizon scan.

All other entries are really good as well, haven't seen any weaker one, so it shows how great level this contest has.

Avatar for akiranyo
akiranyo Satellizer L. Bridget

3 months, 4 weeks ago

 

TIME FOR THE RESULTS THEN!

first place - Isshi (17 points)

second place - Yamaro (16 points)

third place - Dolce-Yasmin (10 points)

fourth place - Wonderngo (9 points)

fifth place - TheMajor (5 points)

sixth place - akiranyo (4 points)

Other participators:

Vampluva, acidtreat101, 200M, oge, ClockWorkLemons,

kori, SamB

Thank to everybody who joined and helped to win a battle against mainstream series!

Avatar for TheMajor
°TheMajor

3 months, 2 weeks ago

 

Yeah! Fifth, my best finish ever.... Now to build on it.

This thread is closed. You can no longer post in this thread.
Topic Closed